|
|
| Name: ellie |
|
| |
|
| Country: SCOTLAND |
|
Date: 10 Oct 2008 20:54:03 GMT | |
|
Comment: your website ROCKS keep on makeing your cool flies remember to put the ellie bell ellie |
| Name: Bob Frandsen |
|
|
|
| Country: AUSTRALIA |
|
Date: 11 Oct 2008 04:37:41 GMT | |
|
Comment: Hi Colin, looking good , i`ll be following your progress for sure |
| Name: mark j. romero |
|
|
|
| Country: U.S.A. |
|
Date: 11 Oct 2008 08:35:52 GMT | |
|
Comment: VERY cool website.....looking forward to watching it grow. Please link mine to yours.....and i'll do the same for you. mark..... ;>) |
| Name: Kjell-Ove Karlsen |
|
| Welcome Page: |
|
| Country: NORWAY |
|
Date: 11 Oct 2008 18:17:45 GMT | |
|
Comment: Hi. Loooks so good, hope you post pics of all your old flies, i really love to look at them. All the best. K-O |
| Name: Nick Moses |
|
| Welcome Page: http://rivererewashrestorationproject.blogspot.com/ |
|
| Country: UNITED KINGDOM |
|
Date: 13 Oct 2008 11:27:30 GMT | |
|
Comment: Superb website, lots of useful information. I'm looking forward to hearing more about Aberdeen's rodmakers. |
| Name: Clive Edwards |
|
| Welcome Page: http://www.richardwheatleymuseum.org |
|
| Country: U.K. |
|
Date: 13 Oct 2008 15:33:49 GMT | |
|
Comment: Well done... interesting website...look forward to watching it's development. Please consider linking to the Richard Wheatley Museum. |
| Name: arkle |
|
| Welcome Page: |
|
| Country: ENGLAND |
|
Date: 13 Oct 2008 16:09:23 GMT | |
|
Comment: Lovely site Colin, like the others I'm looking forward to seeing it grow. Not the easiest to find, but got here eventually, the wonders of google. |
| Name: ellie innes |
|
| Welcome Page: |
|
| Country: EDINBURGH |
|
Date: 14 Oct 2008 18:40:45 GMT | |
|
Comment: i love your website i am looking forward to seeing the elle-bell best wishes ellie |
| Name: Chris Knox |
|
| Welcome Page: |
|
| Country: ENGLAND |
|
Date: 15 Oct 2008 05:30:52 GMT | |
|
Comment: Nice one !!!! |
| Name: Bary Grewcock |
|
| Welcome Page: |
|
| Country: SCOTLAND |
|
Date: 15 Oct 2008 08:54:07 GMT | |
|
Comment: This site is now at the top of my "Favourites". Would hate to miss any additions. Good luck |
| Name: Richard Mason |
|
| Welcome Page: http://bowriveradventures.googlepages.com/home |
|
| Country: CANADA |
|
Date: 15 Oct 2008 12:32:38 GMT | |
|
Comment: hi all from canada ,what a wonderfull site you have, i truely enjoyed it , i have a few classic reels in my collection and use them when i guide on bamboo rods , i have a fondness for dingleys and young's , hardys and i even have a sweet older sharps scottie reel with red agate , was so nice to read your pages , well done , come for a fish sometime in canada with me on the bow river , canada's # 1 best trout river |
| Name: Chris Western |
|
| Welcome Page: |
|
| Country: SCOTLAND, ABERDEENSHIRE |
|
Date: 15 Oct 2008 14:39:50 GMT | |
|
Comment: Great site Colin, well done. I have a couple of Dee's for you, let me know where to send them. Looking forward to the book. Regards Chris. |
| Name: Malcolm Thorne |
|
| Welcome Page: |
|
| Country: UNITED KINGDOM |
|
Date: 15 Oct 2008 16:03:23 GMT | |
|
Comment: Looking forward to the book, but a fine website. Congratulations will be in order when the book is finely published!!!!! |
| Name: Rocky Maley |
Email: |
| Welcome Page: |
|
| Country: USA |
IP Address: |
Date: 17 Oct 2008 09:45:29 GMT | |
|
Comment: Great site Colin i check it every day. I love looking at the old flies Rocky |
| Name: James Montoya |
Email: |
| Welcome Page: |
|
| Country: COLORADO U.S |
IP Address: |
Date: 19 Oct 2008 05:09:22 GMT | |
|
Comment: I love your web site nice to see all the vintage flies and takele. Keep up with the great work and I look forward to seeing more. thanks James |
| Name: Graham Nicol |
Email: |
| Welcome Page: |
|
| Country: UK |
IP Address: |
Date: 22 Oct 2008 07:50:34 GMT | |
|
Comment: Being an Aberdonian a lot of this will bring back memoriesof Brown's and Dicksons in Belmont Street. |
| Name: Paul Moore |
Email: |
| Welcome Page: |
|
| Country: CANADA |
IP Address: |
Date: 26 Oct 2008 13:12:09 GMT | |
|
Comment: Nicely done, looking forward to your book. Please keep the site updated on the book's progress, title and release date. Info on J S Sharpe is great, |
| Name: Dennis P, Lee |
Email: |
| Welcome Page: |
|
| Country: CALIFORNIA USA |
IP Address: |
Date: 3 Nov 2008 17:52:40 GMT | |
|
Comment: Excellent website with lots of great information. Looking forward to future visits. DPLee |
| Name: caihlen |
Email: |
| Welcome Page: |
|
| Country: USA |
IP Address: |
Date: 4 Nov 2008 15:14:35 GMT | |
|
Comment: Very Very Nice |
| Name: Steve Silverio | Email: steve@silverfishflies.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: USA | IP Address: 71.242.110.48 | Date: 6 Nov 2008 17:30:40 GMT | | | Comment: Hello Colin,
Very nice meeting you at the British Fly Fair, I hope we get the chance to meet again. I've thoroughly enjoyed browsing your website. |
| Name: Barry Grewcock | Email: barryg1@tiscali.co.uk | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: SCOTLAND | IP Address: 88.109.79.171 | Date: 6 Nov 2008 18:58:36 GMT | | | Comment: Colin,
Please post the P-T article you mention in "cool stuff". I'm sure a lot of people would be very interested in it.
Website is progressing very well. Still one of my first ports of call
Barry |
| Name: Robert Taylor | Email: retaylor1@msn.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: USA | IP Address: 68.207.218.81 | Date: 8 Nov 2008 15:29:15 GMT | | | Comment: Colin this is a very nice and informative site. I am going to bookmark it and will visit every so often.
Bob |
| Name: Joshua Parks | Email: | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: USA | IP Address: 74.34.137.13 | Date: 3 Dec 2008 07:06:31 GMT | | | Comment: Great Site!! Love the vintage Dee's!! Marked as a favorite! |
| Name: Jim Carpenter | Email: jec38@cox.net | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: USA | IP Address: 72.223.44.36 | Date: 3 Dec 2008 15:57:50 GMT | | | Comment: Outstanding web site, and very interesting subject. The Dee, it's people, fishing, and history has always fasinated me. |
| Name: Stack Scoville | Email: | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: U.S.A. | IP Address: 68.53.113.154 | Date: 8 Dec 2008 04:09:36 GMT | | | Comment: Colin,
My congratulations on an exceptional site. Something here for everyone. The history of patterns and flies (especailly to little known and obscure) is especially interesting to me. Thank you for your work on this site and also to those who have contributed infomation for you to include. |
| Name: Tam Gair | Email: tam.gair@btopenworld.com | | Welcome Page: http://www.vintagefishingtackle-uk.com | | | Country: SCOTLAND | IP Address: 86.166.27.109 | Date: 12 Dec 2008 12:37:41 GMT | | | Comment: Excellent Site Colin , Keep up the good work. |
| Name: Ken Reid | Email: ken@riverdee.org | | Welcome Page: http://www.fishdee.co.uk | | | Country: SCOTLAND | IP Address: 86.141.253.192 | Date: 15 Dec 2008 15:01:43 GMT | | | Comment: Colin
Thanks for taking time to contact me and make me aware about your informative site.I will promote it through some contacts and mediums which will assist you reach a wide base of viewers.Best wishes with your endeavours and congratulations for producing suc good reference material.
Ken Reid
DDSFB
Aberdeenshire |
| Name: David Ramsay | Email: david.ramsay1@gmail.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: CURRENTLY EGYPT, SOON THAILAND BUT HOME IN ABOYNE | IP Address: 129.230.248.1 | Date: 15 Dec 2008 15:30:14 GMT | | | Comment: Good site; I know a lot of research has gone into this at various places up and down the river (The Boat Inn, Potties, to name only two). Looking forward to having a few casts with you at Tannar Mouth with Alex in the new year. Great site, Dave |
| Name: Mike St. Clair | Email: mike@schflyrods.com | | Welcome Page: http://www.schflyrods.com | | | Country: U.S.A. | IP Address: 75.23.162.228 | Date: 20 Dec 2008 23:54:27 GMT | | | Comment: Very cool website! Fascinating artifacts, facts, and fables. Too bad you can't put a nice Scot accent on all the descriptions... just for effect.
Thanks for sharing a wealth of information. |
| Name: DONALD R. MACLEOD | Email: | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: | IP Address: 92.41.97.7 | Date: 27 Dec 2008 08:54:24 GMT | | | Comment: Just read your biog. I have evidently confused you with another Colin Innes who is a solicitor in Edinburgh! Sorry! Donald |
| Name: Dave | Email: dhsandstrom@yahoo.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: U.S.A. | IP Address: 4.242.177.184 | Date: 31 Dec 2008 04:35:34 GMT | | | Comment: Hi Colin, I am interested in obtaining information on Hugh Snowie of Inverness and would appreciate any information or references regarding his life, business, or family, that you know of. |
| Name: DONALD R. MACLEOD | Email: donald.macleod@advocates.org.uk | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND | IP Address: 92.41.6.158 | Date: 6 Jan 2009 06:30:02 GMT | | | Comment: Dear Colin,
Surely the missing "Benkle" is the "Benchill" named after the Tay beat? It strikes me that we are dealing with uneducated spelling in some local quarter here. Yours aye, Donald |
| Name: Stephen Carney | Email: stephen.carney2@ntlworld.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: ENGLAND | IP Address: 86.22.228.88 | Date: 7 Jan 2009 10:46:05 GMT | | | Comment: Inspired Site, I'll be visiting frequently |
| Name: Lornce | Email: doc_rocket@shaw.ca | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: CANADA | IP Address: 68.145.76.50 | Date: 17 Jan 2009 05:32:24 GMT | | | Comment: Wonderful resource to brows through. Thanks your for your hard work. |
| Name: DONALD R. MACLEOD | Email: donald.macleod@advocates.org.uk | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND | IP Address: 92.41.224.254 | Date: 21 Jan 2009 06:16:49 GMT | | | Comment: This post concerns the Spey flies series in Knox's book of 1872. First the Riach series which Knox calls "Reeach". If only dear old Knox had realised how this mis-spelling grates with the Scots. The name is Riach, with the "ch" pronounced as in the Scots word for a lake namely "loch", not as in the word "reach". The surname Riach derives from the old Scots Gaelic word for "royal". I think I may have identified the man Riach after whom these flies are called. He was a prominent businessman and civic councillor in the area in the nineteenth century. More info soon. As to the Speal series. The word "speal", pronounced "spyal" is the Scots Gaelic word for a scythe. Look at the shape of the wing of the fly. It is just like a scythe-blade. Gaelic started to disappear from Dee-side shortly after the Reformation but many of the Gaelic names in the locality are preserved to this day - see "The Place-names of Upper Deeside" published by Aberdeen University Press about 1980. As for Speyside, well, without keeping the Gaelic associations, a whole lot of distilleries would go out of business! |
| Name: Dave | Email: strathmhor@hotmail.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: SCOTLAND | IP Address: 81.156.2.74 | Date: 29 Jan 2009 20:30:00 GMT | | | Comment: Fascinating site - Superb achievement |
| Name: bud guidry | Email: cod@mobiletel.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: US | IP Address: 208.97.44.243 | Date: 30 Jan 2009 08:42:13 GMT | | | Comment: wonderful and useful site colin. i'll be around often, Bud |
| Name: Grant Chapman | Email: chappie.lou@xtra.co.nz | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: NEW ZEALAND | IP Address: 222.154.106.227 | Date: 17 Feb 2009 06:43:39 GMT | | | Comment: Wow, I am most impressed. Bought a JS Sharpe Rod the other day and was just looking it up and found your site. I've been collecting for 3 or so years and have a few items I need to identify so my contact you again idf that is acceptable.
Cheers
Chappie |
| Name: Edward Muzzy Muzeroll | Email: eamuzer@fairpoint.net | | Welcome Page: http://www.muzzysflies.com | | | Country: UNITED STATES | IP Address: 66.243.207.126 | Date: 6 Mar 2009 15:40:41 GMT | | | Comment: Hello Colin,
I see I will be spending some time on this lovely website.
Cheers,
Muzzy |
| Name: Manfred | Email: manfred.H.muhl@hotmail.de | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: GERMANY | IP Address: 84.176.228.179 | Date: 13 Mar 2009 17:18:26 GMT | | | Comment: very nice website - using sometie my 8.3scottie with my gordon reel - amazing troutfishing - go ahead pls |
| Name: john brown | Email: johnk.brown@hotmail.co.uk | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: SCOTLAND | IP Address: 86.142.138.134 | Date: 31 Mar 2009 23:41:14 GMT | | | Comment: a lot of work done here mate, looking forward to its progress |
| Name: Dai Jones | Email: d.jones793@ntlworld.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: WALES | IP Address: 86.16.200.220 | Date: 3 Apr 2009 14:02:20 GMT | | | Comment: Colin, great site, loads of info look for ward to seeing site grow. |
| Name: Neil Houlding | Email: nhoulding@rogers.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: CANADA/ORIGINALY UK. | IP Address: 72.141.252.128 | Date: 7 Apr 2009 01:35:22 GMT | | | Comment: Hi Colin.
Great site mate.
I just fished Dee last week,wish I could have paid you a visit for a chat and a pint.
I went to visit Somers but they were closed unfortunately.
Keep up the great work/site.
Best Regards Neil. |
| Name: paul martin | Email: paullin1@myfairpoint.net | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: MAINE USA | IP Address: 198.182.163.125 | Date: 7 Apr 2009 20:05:08 GMT | | | Comment: I wish I had found this site a long time ago. This is not just a great web site, it's a brilliant historical resource. I am in you debt and that will only grow as I spend more time looking around, studying and benefit from all that is there! |
| Name: Greg Asbury | Email: | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: MONTANA, USA | IP Address: 72.175.202.15 | Date: 15 Apr 2009 21:10:55 GMT | | | Comment: I came upon your site while trying to find more of W. Murdochs writings about flies for the Dee. Very cool! I particularly like the pictures and illustrations of vintage flies. I am a fly tier, and it's really good to see what they looked like when they were originated. I just added you to my faforites. Very nice! |
| Name: Alan Maule | Email: skaro12002@yahoo.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND | IP Address: 82.41.60.252 | Date: 30 Apr 2009 22:28:42 GMT | | | Comment: Fantastic website,very interesting.
Any info on Edinburgh tackle makers?
All the best,
Alan. |
| Name: James McLeod | Email: speytrout@yahoo.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: US | IP Address: 99.36.135.64 | Date: 17 Jul 2009 01:54:10 GMT | | | Comment: VEry Cool! loads of info on here. |
| Name: Jeff Dickey | Email: jeffrey_dickey2@homedepot.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: TEXAS | IP Address: 165.130.136.206 | Date: 2 Aug 2009 17:26:09 GMT | | | Comment: Superb website, Colin. I visit all the time, just gettin around to signing in. Thanks for all of the fascinating information!
-Jeff |
| Name: frederick | Email: frederick.burt@sky.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: ENGLAND | IP Address: 94.3.114.131 | Date: 5 Aug 2009 19:22:02 GMT | | | Comment: Great site Colin, its "Ellie Belle" for me.
Frederick. UK. |
| Name: Joel Stansbury | Email: joelst1@windstream.net | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: USA | Date: 25 Sep 2009 19:04:35 GMT | | | Comment: Colin, wonderful site!I see a lot of friends have beaten me here.Let us all know when your book comes out.I know John Shewey is coming out with another book on Spey flies also. His first book has always been my bible up to now.Say Hi to Phillip Glendinning. He's a hard man to keep in touch with.
Cheers, Joel |
| Name: Rick Mackay | Email: | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: P.E.I CANADA | Date: 18 Oct 2009 17:28:28 GMT | | | Comment: Hi Colin, your site is one of the best the fly plates,patterns and imformation
is just great to see. All the best. |
| Name: sarah briston | Email: sarahbriston@hotmail.com | | Welcome Page: http://www.classicflyart.com | | | Country: SCOTLAND- MORAY | Date: 25 Oct 2009 16:43:18 GMT | | | Comment: Colin your website is a fascinating, very good job in archiving Aberdeens flies, Are you going to the BFFI if so I will hope to catch up with you there.
Best Regards Sarah |
| Name: T. Kjær Jensen | Email: t.kjaer.jensen@gmail.dk | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: DANMARK | Date: 26 Oct 2009 22:46:21 GMT | | | Comment: You have created a very interesting site, i will visit it very often. Interesting to see a picture of colin simpson and of the huts by river dee |
| Name: Tim | Email: timcole64@googlemail.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: ENGLAND | Date: 10 Nov 2009 23:26:08 GMT | | | Comment: Brilliant site and very informative. Will definitely buy the book. Recognise your picture from seeing you at tackle auctions. I have a number of vintage flies in my collection and will try and find some which may be of use |
| Name: john jenkins | Email: jenksjohn@aql.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: GB | Date: 13 Nov 2009 01:08:10 GMT | | | Comment: exellent web sight, enjoyed the fly archive, look forward to the book |
| Name: Richard Donkin | Email: richard.donkin@gmail.com | | Welcome Page: http://www.richarddonkin.com | | | Country: UK | Date: 1 Dec 2009 08:36:44 GMT | | | Comment: Colin,
I am linking to your site immediately. It's an important catalogue that deserves much broader recognition and I'm sure it will achieve that.
|
| Name: Brian | Email: | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: CANADA | Date: 28 Jan 2010 20:44:53 GMT | | | Comment: I have always liked fly fishing and your site is great.I will email my brother out west the link. |
| Name: Fraser Henderson | Email: frashend@clear.net.nz | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: NEW ZEALAND | Date: 24 Feb 2010 22:59:58 GMT | | | Comment: Ernest Calder, gunmaker, founded his shop at 67/69 King St in 1913. He was the son of William Calder of Guild St. Ernest Calder's shop closed in 1959.
The "branch" of William Calder in George St was probably a shop of Grace Calder, his daughter.
Ernest is my grandfather. |
| Name: Bruce E Harang | Email: flydresser258@gmail.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: WASHINGTON, USA | Date: 28 Mar 2010 19:31:07 GMT | | | Comment: I have been looking for a pattern with a mohair wing and found one on your lovely site. Thank you for a great resource. Now to the tying bench to give it a go. |
| Name: Dwayne Miller | Email: flyfishj@pei.sympatico.ca | | Welcome Page: http://www.flyfishtheisland.com | | | Country: CANADA | Date: 4 Apr 2010 03:13:49 GMT | | | Comment: I have an ongoing love-affair with Dee patterns and to be honest,, I think i have found a new home!!!!! Just an amazing site you have here Colin!!! |
| Name: J Daeschler | Email: enquiry@imperialgunco.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: UK | Date: 4 Aug 2010 14:19:19 GMT | | | Comment: Great website, I like the historical elements. My youth was spent in Aberdeen working for a gunsmiths there so some of these names are very familiar to me as gunmakers as well as fishing tackle makers. Playfair is the name that sticks out for me due to the important gun making business. Both Charles Playfair( I) and John Lyell have nice headstones in the King Street Cemetery in Aberdeen. |
| Name: Stewart Dee | Email: | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: USA | Date: 23 Aug 2010 05:35:21 GMT | | | Comment: One of the best sites for an incredible journey through classic fishing, thank you. |
| Name: Dave Sharpe | Email: dsboz@aol.com | | Welcome Page: | | | Country: MONTANA, USA | Date: 28 Aug 2010 00:45:24 GMT | | | Comment: Obviously my interest springs from my namesake. And I'll be darned if old J.S. doesn't look just like my grandfather. Appreciate the fine effort you've made here!
Would love to hear more about Sharpe's rods especially the trout rods, their histories, values and their actions. ie: what action would a Featherweight 8' 6" have? What line would best fit it? Where would it fall in a quality ranking of Sharpe rods.
Would also enjoy learning more about The Gordon reels.
Thanks so much! Dave |
|
|

|